A Los Angeles County judge has dismissed a federally filed lawsuit for Rank and File Police Officers against the LAPD commander accused of accessing emails, investigations and materials exclusively to subordinate officers.
In Monday’s ruling, LA County Superior Court Judge Bruce Iwasaki was on the side of CMDR. Lillian Carranza and her co-defendant, Deputy Director Marc Reina, alleged that the Los Angeles Police Protection League failed to prove any allegations of illegal computer data access and fraud.
Iwasaki writes that the league has failed to make a clear allegation of “damage or loss” that resulted in Karanza’s actions focused on accessing union investigations for members below the captain’s rank. Karanza and the other commanders have their own unions.
Among other legal technologies, Iwasaki writes that the company’s investigation Monkey owns the investigation in question, not the league.
The lawsuit was dismissed “defense.” That is, it cannot be reconsidered.
Karanza refused to discuss the verdict when it arrived this week, saying she wanted to first explore her legal options.
Reina, who runs the departmental office that oversees training and recruitment, did not respond to a request for comment. Until recently, he also served as president of the Los Angeles Police Commander.
The league lawsuit filed last year accused Carranza of separating himself as a subordinate officer, visiting the union’s website and filling out an investigation to score supervisors. Carranza filed in court that she used her name on login, noting that she and other command staff have used the league’s system on a daily basis to access the benefits of the agency.
In a letter to the Commanders’ Union last December, league President Craig Larry said that commanders’ access to the “benefit portal” would be blocked by the end of the year.
The voicemail that left for Larry was not returned Thursday.
League officials say the digital forensics company was hired to investigate the issue. Karanza discovered that the union had opened about 49 “confidential emails” that it sent from 2016 to 2024.
The lawsuit comes amid a fierce dispute between the league and Karanza, the outspoken commander of the LAPD central office.
The league followed Caranza, called for press conferences, released YouTube videos and performed shows featuring subtle shots on the pages of the monthly magazine Thin Blue Line. Karanza further drew the league’s rage when she came to the defense of a female captain who insisted on conducting a Force use investigation into cases involving two officers.
The union claims that the department’s morale is low as members include most LAPD officers, detectives, sergeants and eu – Karanza and other commanders lack accountability.
In addition to publicly criticizing Carranza, the union has also selected other high-ranking officials, namely Reina and Michael Rimkunas, another vice chief who oversees the internal investigation.
Carranza, who was promoted to captain in 2012 and commander in 2023, applied for the LAPD Chief job that was left vacant when Michelle Moore retired in February 2024. Sources previously said that Karanza was one of many candidates invited to the second round of the interview.
Source link
