Picture books are not usually from the Supreme Court decision. However, on Friday, the majority of judges ruled that parents have the right to select their children from lessons that anger religious beliefs. We have brought colorful books pages such as “Uncle Bobby’s Wedding” and “Pride Puppy” to the stable public records of the country’s Supreme Court.
The ruling stems from a lawsuit filed by parents in Montgomery County, Maryland, which sues the right to remove children from lessons read out loud by the LGBTQ+ Storybook in elementary school classes from kindergarten to fifth grade. The book was part of a district’s efforts to represent LGBTQ+ families in the English Arts curriculum.
In its decision 6-3, the Supreme Court ruled that if one of the disputed picture books is used in a child’s class, the school must “notify in advance” so that the school can temporarily remove them. Three Liberal parties in the court disputed.
As part of the decision, briefings and petitions in this case, parents’ justice and lawyers detailed the stories of nine picture books that are part of Montgomery County’s new curriculum. To her opposition, Judge Sonia Sotomayor perfectly recreated “Uncle Bobby’s Wedding.”
These are the nine books that were the subject of the incident:
Pride Puppy
Author: Robin Stevenson
Illustrator: Julie McLaughlin
A book called “Pride Puppy” published by Orca Book Publishers.
(Orca Book Publishers)
“Pride Puppy,” a rhyming alphabet book for very young children, depicts a girl who loses her dog during a fun visit to the Pride Parade. A story that can be obtained as a board book invites readers to include items starting with each letter of the alphabet, such as Apple, Baseball, and Cloud, as well as specific items in the Pride Parade.
The lawyer representing his parents said he would invite students to invite students old enough to tie their shoes in search of images of “underwear,” “leather,” and “lip rings.”[drag] With the King'[drag] Queen and “Masha P. Johnson,” a controversial LGBTQ activist and sex worker. ”
The “leather” in question refers to the mother’s jacket and the “underwear” in green briefs worn by an older child in tights as part of the colorful outfit.
Montgomery County public schools have stopped teaching “pride puppies” during the middle of a legal battle.
Love, Violet
Author: Charlotte Sullivan Wild
Illustrator: Charlene Chure
A book about “Love Violet” published by Macmillan Publishers.
(McMillan)
The story describes a little girl named Violet who fell in love with another girl in her class who “leaps and laughs” and “makes a skip of Violet’s heart.” However, every time Mira tries to talk to her, Violet becomes shy and quiet.
On Valentine’s Day, Violet makes Mira a special Valentine’s Day. Valentine is stomped down in the snow as Violet gathers the courage to give her. But Mira loves it anyway, and there’s also a special gift for Violet. At the end of the book, the two girls go on an adventure together.
The parents’ lawyers describe “Love, Violet” as a book about “two young girls and their same-sex playground romance.” They say, “Teachers are encouraged to have a “voice” moment, and students are encouraged to ask how they feel when they feel like “just” and “like someone.” ”
Born Preparation: The True Story of a Boy Named Penelope
Author: Jody Patterson
Illustrator: Charnelle Pinkney Barlow
A book called Born Ready published by Random House.
(Random House)
In “Born Ready,” Penelope, 5, was born as a girl, but she is sure they are boys.
“I love you, mommy, but I don’t want to be you. I don’t want to be daddy. I don’t want to come tomorrow as tomorrow looks like you. Help Mom. Help me become a boy,” Penelope tells their mother. “We make plans to tell everyone we know,” Penelope’s mother tells them, and they throw a big party to celebrate.
On her opposition, Sotomayor says, “When Penelope’s brothers express their skepticism, his mother says, “Not everything needs to make sense. This is about love.” ”
In the opening brief, the family lawyer said, “Teachers are told to instruct people to speculate about our gender,” but “we know ourselves best.” ”
The prince and the knight
Author: Daniel Hack
Illustrator: Stevie Lewis
“The Prince and the Knight” is about a prince whose parents want him to find a bride, but instead he falls in love with the Knight. Together, they fight the dragon. When the prince falls from a great height, his knight rides a horse to save him.
When the king and queen found their love, they were “overwhelmed by joy.” We finally found the perfect person for our boy! “A wonderful wedding was held, and “The Prince and his shining knight will live happily ever after.”
“The Prince & Night book clearly conveys the message that same-sex marriage should be accepted by all as a source of celebration,” said Judge Samuel Alito, who wrote the majority opinion.
“For young children whose targets are this and other picture books, such celebrations tend to be treated as having moral implications,” writes Alito. “If this same-sex marriage leads to happiness for everyone and joyous celebrations for everyone, then that’s a good thing in every way?”
Uncle Bobby’s wedding
Author: Sarah S. Brannen
Illustrator: Lucia Soto
In “Uncle Bobby’s Wedding,” a little girl named Chloe learns that her beloved uncle is engaged to his partner, a man named Jamie. At first, she worries that marriage will change the close bond with her uncle. However, she soon accepts the celebration and joy of acquiring another uncle through the union.
In many opinions, Alito wrote that the book sends a message to children that “whether they are the same or the opposite sex, they can get married as long as they “love each other.” “That perspective “is directly contrary to the religious principle that parents in this case want to instill in their children.” Parents’ ability to “present alternative moral messages” to their children is undermined when the exact opposite message is actively strengthened in public school classrooms at very young ages,” he said.
On her contrary, Sotomayor includes the entire book, writing, “Because the majority selectively excerpt the book to rewrite its story.”
The majority analysis reveals that “they can’t accept and explain basic truths. There are LGBTQ people. They are part of virtually every community and workplace of a considerable size. Eliminating books depicting LGBTQ individuals willingly accept by their families does not rule out student exposure to that concept.”
Jacob’s choice room
Authors: Sarah Hoffman and Ian Hoffman
Illustrator: Chris Case
This book is “Jacob’s Room to Shoie” published by Magination Press.
(Magination Press)
“Jacob’s Selected Room” is a follow-up to “Jacob’s New Dress.” This is a picture book listed as one of the top 100 books in Asun from the American Library of America’s top 100 books of the past decade.
Jacob is wearing a dress and when he tries to use the boy’s toilet, two little boys “look at Jacob standing in the doorway. Jacob knew how it looked. The same thing happens to his friend Sophie. He exists as a boy and is kicked out of the girl’s bathroom.
Their teachers encourage the entire class to rethink what gender really means. The class decides that anyone can feel comfortable using the bathroom and decides to create a new comprehensive sign to hang on the bathroom door.
“After relaxing the bathroom door to welcome multiple genders, the kids parade with placards declaring that “bathroom is for all bunnies.”[choose] A comfortable bathroom,” wrote the parents’ lawyer.
Crossroads: We create space for everyone
Author: Chelsea Johnson, Latoya Council, Carolyn Che
Illustrator: Ashley Seil Smith
Write a book “All the Crossroads: Creating a Room for Everything” published by Dottir Press.
(Dottir Press)
Written by three sociologists, “The Crossroads” is a story about characters with different identities, including people who use wheelchairs, and another Kate who identifies as transgender. One page shows Kate, a gender-neutral bathroom, saying, “My friends will protect my choices and places. Bathrooms like every room should be safe spaces.”
In many opinions, Alito describes the discussion guides included in the books he argues. “When we are born, our gender is determined for us based on our gender. This guide asks readers, “What is the pronoun that you best suits?” Alito wrote.
What are your words? : A book about pronouns
Author: Katherine Rock
Illustrator: Anne Passchier
“What are your words?” says, “It’s like the weather. They change depending on my feelings, because that’s my words.” Ali’s uncle Rior (who uses their pronouns) is visiting and Ali is struggling to decide which words to describe.
“Children spend days suffering from correct pronouns,” the parents’ lawyer wrote. Finally, Ali says while watching the fireworks.
My rainbow
Author: Deshanna Neal and Trinity Neal
Illustrator: Art Tink
“My Rainbow” tells the true story of an autistic black child who self-identifies as a transgender girl. Trinity wants long hair like her doll, but she struggles to grow it. “The mother decides that the child knows best and sews a rainbow wig,” the parents’ lawyer wrote.
Montgomery County Public Schools have stopped teaching “my rainbow” during the course of the lawsuit.
This article is part of the Times Early Childhood Education Initiative and focuses on learning and development for California children from birth to age 5. To learn more about the initiative and its charity funders, visit latimes.com/earlyed.
Source link
